Boring Money

Boring Money

Share this post

Boring Money
Boring Money
Quant's mutual funds might have some front-running
User's avatar
Discover more from Boring Money
Stories about finance in India. Some chaotic, all fun.
Over 5,000 subscribers
Already have an account? Sign in

Quant's mutual funds might have some front-running

Who's the sucker for whom Quant's magic powder wasn't enough?

Shreedhar Manek's avatar
Shreedhar Manek
Jul 01, 2024
9

Share this post

Boring Money
Boring Money
Quant's mutual funds might have some front-running
2
1
Share
Horses are good at running in front.

I’m trying something new. If you’ve written something nice and would like an audience for it, I would love to re-publish it on Boring Money. It doesn’t even have to be anything finance related. Share what you’ve got to shreedhar@boringmoney.in

(I’m going to have a very high bar on quality.)


Let’s revisit how front-running works:

  1. You figure out that a large investor is going to buy a particular stock.

  2. You buy that stock before the large investor.

  3. You turn around and sell the stock to the large investor.

  4. Profit? Maybe, assuming you’re able to buy low, sell high.

The profitability of this trade depends on the liquidity of the stock (or the lack of it). If there are a lot of people buying and selling the stock that you’re trying to front-run, the large investor might get all the stock they want without moving its price a lot. But if there aren’t too many traders in the stock, the large investor buying will push the price up.

With this in mind, here’s a report from Moneycontrol last week:

The market regulator Sebi has conducted search and seizure operations on Sandeep Tandon-owned Quant Mutual Fund suspecting front-running as part of a probe into suspected front-running, three people familiar with the development said. The search and seizure operation was conducted across two locations – Mumbai and Hyderabad.

…

Although two of the people cited confirmed that the case relates to front-running, the exact nature of the allegations could not be ascertained. One person said that the alleged profits from the transactions being probed by Sebi are close to Rs 20 crore. However, it is not clear if the management is under investigation in this case, or whether the probe relate only to external parties.

SEBI is investigating asset manager Quant Mutual Fund because apparently someone at the fund is front-running its trades.1 SEBI probably found a pattern of shady buying/selling on its monitoring systems and is now looking for concrete evidence. Still early stuff. But people are worried! Quant’s mutual funds have been beating pretty much every other fund in the market in most categories. It’s almost been as if Quant has some magic powder that it sprinkles on its mutual funds and they end up topping the charts.

Magic powder aside, one thing Quant does do is buy a lot of small company stock.2 Stock that is usually less liquid than large company stock. That’s what adds to people’s worries—Quant invests in small companies with less floating stock and there’s a fair bit of front-running potential here.

If someone at Quant is indeed front-running its trades, the main losers are the mutual fund’s investors. The front-runner skims away some of the potential profits of the fund and investors consequently make a little bit less than they would otherwise. But… Quant’s funds have been doing great! Better than everyone else! Does it matter that there is a bit of skimming happening?

Well, sort of. It depends on who is doing the skimming. If the front-running is being done by a fund manager, that’s bad! Sure, the fund is performing well, but if a fund manager—who makes investment decisions—is making money front-running, he no longer wants Quant’s funds to buy the stock that he expects to do well, but instead wants the fund to buy the stock that he expects to be able to front-run. And of course these would be small companies with less liquid stock.

But the front-runner need not be a fund manager! Last year, SEBI had similarly investigated Axis Mutual Fund for some front-running. The main culprit there was Viren Joshi, who used to be the “chief dealer” at Axis. The chief dealer and his team execute the trades that are decided by the fund manager. The fund manager might decide that he wants to buy $1 billion of a particular company’s stock, but he isn’t going to spend time figuring out at what times of the day(s) to execute the order to get the best price, or which brokers to send the order to. This is operational stuff that the chief dealer and the dealing team handle.

The chief dealer sits between the investment team (which includes the fund manager) and the brokers with whom the orders are placed. There couldn’t be a more convenient position for a front-runner.

I don’t know who at Quant is front-running its trades but if it ends up being someone from the dealing team, it might not be too bad. Minus the front-running, the fund will get better prices for the stocks it buys and its performance will get even better. If it turns out to be a fund manager though it could mean the fund is filled with illiquid stocks which cannot be sold.3

Leave a comment

Cover Photo by Helena Lopes/Pexels

1

Disclosure: A portion of my investments is in one of Quant’s funds.

2

For context, HDFC’s Flexi Cap fund has 74% of its assets in large companies at the moment, while the corresponding figure for Quant’s Flexi Cap fund is just about 56%.

3

Without massively crashing the prices of those stocks, that is.

Ved's avatar
Shubham's avatar
Priyanka Kothari's avatar
Abhinav Chauhan's avatar
Sohang Chopra's avatar
9 Likes∙
1 Restack
9

Share this post

Boring Money
Boring Money
Quant's mutual funds might have some front-running
2
1
Share

Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sohang Chopra's avatar
Sohang Chopra
Jul 1, 2024

Do you think it's a good idea to still continue SIP in Quant despite these allegations?

Expand full comment
Like (1)
Reply
Share
1 reply by Shreedhar Manek
1 more comment...
Reliance pays a hell ton of money to a company that runs a pump-and-dump
The more you learn, the less sense things make
Feb 1 • 
Shreedhar Manek
57

Share this post

Boring Money
Boring Money
Reliance pays a hell ton of money to a company that runs a pump-and-dump
2
Adani stocks only go up
Or how a hypothetical marble manufacturing company could increase its share price
Sep 25, 2022 • 
Shreedhar Manek
45

Share this post

Boring Money
Boring Money
Adani stocks only go up
3
IndusInd was on fire and the CEO was selling stock
Knowing things affects your general behaviour, including the business decisions you make
Jun 21 • 
Shreedhar Manek
22

Share this post

Boring Money
Boring Money
IndusInd was on fire and the CEO was selling stock
2

Ready for more?

© 2025 Shreedhar Manek
Publisher Privacy ∙ Publisher Terms
Substack
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Create your profile

User's avatar

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.